Heterogeneous Determinism Across Stocks and Scales: A Multiscale RQA Analysis of 5-Minute Financial Data

Thesis title: Heterogeneous Determinism Across Stocks and Scales: A Multiscale RQA Analysis of 5-Minute Financial Data
Author: Mashburn, Calum
Thesis type: Diploma thesis
Supervisor: Brůna, Karel
Opponents: Tran, Van Quang
Thesis language: English
Abstract:
Abstract The null hypothesis of linear stochasticity is rejected across the majority of the sample. At 30-minute resolution, all 18 securities achieved significance (100%), with z-scores orders of magnitude beyond what multiple testing or measurement noise could plausibly explain. Market dynamics are found to be strongly scale-dependent: high-frequency dynamics exhibit strong determinism, near-random or anti-persistent Hurst values, and vigorous chaos, while dynamics at lower frequencies show weaker determinism, persistent Hurst exponents, and reduced Lyapunov exponents. Wavelet preprocessing is demonstrated not to create spurious determinism; z-scores collapse by 90–92% with filtering, consistent with genuine high-frequency signal removal rather than artifact generation. Heterogeneity in the magnitude of dynamical structure across securities suggests that not all equities inhabit the same dynamical regime, with implications for which instruments and timescales are most amenable to quantitative analysis strategies. The findings support a characterization of equity and futures markets as exhibiting scale-dependent stochastic-chaotic dynamics, and challenge both the random walk hypothesis and scale-invariant fractal market models.
Keywords: Recurrance quantification analysis; Lyapunov exponents; IAAFT surrogates
Thesis title: Heterogeneous Deterministic Signatures Across Stocks and Scales: A Multiscale RQA Analysis of Intraday Financial Data
Author: Mashburn, Calum
Thesis type: Diplomová práce
Supervisor: Brůna, Karel
Opponents: Tran, Van Quang
Thesis language: English
Abstract:
Abstract The null hypothesis of linear stochasticity is rejected across the majority of the sample. At 30-minute resolution, all 18 securities achieved significance (100%), with z-scores orders of magnitude beyond what multiple testing or measurement noise could plausibly explain. Market dynamics are found to be strongly scale-dependent: high-frequency dynamics exhibit strong determinism, near-random or anti-persistent Hurst values, and vigorous chaos, while dynamics at lower frequencies show weaker determinism, persistent Hurst exponents, and reduced Lyapunov exponents. Wavelet preprocessing is demonstrated not to create spurious determinism; z-scores collapse by 90–92% with filtering, consistent with genuine high-frequency signal removal rather than artifact generation. Heterogeneity in the magnitude of dynamical structure across securities suggests that not all equities inhabit the same dynamical regime, with implications for which instruments and timescales are most amenable to quantitative analysis strategies. The findings support a characterization of equity and futures markets as exhibiting scale-dependent stochastic-chaotic dynamics, and challenge both the random walk hypothesis and scale-invariant fractal market models.
Keywords: recurrance quantificiation analysis; IAAFT surrogates; Lyapunov exponents

Information about study

Study programme: Finance and Accounting
Type of study programme: Magisterský studijní program
Assigned degree: Ing.
Institutions assigning academic degree: Vysoká škola ekonomická v Praze
Faculty: Faculty of Finance and Accounting
Department: Department of Monetary Theory and Policy

Information on submission and defense

Date of assignment: 9. 12. 2025
Date of submission: 9. 5. 2026
Date of defense: 9. 6. 2026
Identifier in the InSIS system: https://insis.vse.cz/zp/94872/podrobnosti

Files for download

    Last update: